Showing posts with label north carolina. Show all posts
Showing posts with label north carolina. Show all posts

Saturday, June 27, 2026

The Disappearance of Sara Graham

Image result for sara graham missing"


Sara Graham 
has been missing from Fairmont, North Carolina since February 4th, 2015. That morning, the then-18-year-old Sara borrowed her father’s car to drive to her job at Wal-Mart. She never arrived at work and has never been seen or heard from again.
The car Sara was driving was later found abandoned in an open field. There were no signs of a struggle near the vehicle. According to witnesses, the car was parked there as early as 6:45 AM, but the police did not arrive on the scene until around noon.
Prior to her disappearance, Sara had recently moved to North Carolina from Texas. She moved in with her father and stepmother, who both worked for the sheriff’s department. Her stepmother, Connie Graham, was fired shortly after her disappearance for reasons that have not been released to the public. 
Years passed without any updates in Sara's case. Investigators declined to publicly name any suspects or persons of interest in Sara’s case; however, many locals have shared their own theories on social media. One local rumor is that Sara’s stepbrother was in love/infatuated with Sara and that he killed her when she rejected his advances. This rumor was never confirmed, but over the years, suspicions remained strong about both Sara's stepmother and stepbrother(s). 
Over 11 years later, in June 2026, investigators finally announced a break in the case. Sara's stepmother Connie Graham was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. Connie's sons, Bobby McLellan and Luke Locklear were arrested as well; they were charged with accessory after-the-fact, felony conspiracy and alter/steal/destroy criminal evidence. 
According to warrants, prosecutors believe that Connie killed Sara and then destroyed and altered evidence, such as Sara's bed and the flooring at the home, in order to cover up the crime. It's been alleged that Connie's two sons helped Connie cover up the crime as well. 
Connie and her two sons remain behind bars as their cases are pending. Sara's body has still not been found. If you have any information that could lead to the location of her remains, please submit a tip online.

Monday, December 22, 2025

The Disappearance of Stephanie Lewis

 

Stephanie Lynn Lewis has been missing since October 12th, 2004. The then-21-year-old was in Lumberton, North Carolina at the time of her disappearance. She worked at a local Days Inn on Roberts Avenue.

Stephanie was working the day she vanished. She was last seen walking away from her job at the Days Inn. Before leaving, Stephanie reportedly told others that she was going to try and find a ride to Virginia. She never returned and has never been seen or heard from again.

There is very little information available on Stephanie's disappearance. Various online sources state that she was single at the time she vanished. She left behind a young daughter. There does not appear to be any information about why Stephanie wanted to travel to Virginia, if she intended to ask someone she knew for a ride, or if she intended to hitchhike. 

In 2017, the Lumberton PD made a public appeal for anyone with information about Stephanie's disappearance to come forward. Since then, it appears that there has not been any additional reporting on her case. Stephanie remains missing today, and her case has unfortunately gone cold.

If you have any information that could help solve the disappearance of Stephanie Lewis, please contact the Lumberton Police Department at 910-671-3845.

Tuesday, March 18, 2025

The Disappearance and Death of Angela Burris

Source: Shelby Star

Angela Burris has been missing since April 19th, 2021. The then-36-year-old woman left her residence in Kings Mountain, North Carolina during the early evening. Shortly after, Angela was seen getting into a black sedan driven by an unidentified male. She never returned home and has never been seen or heard from again.

At the time of her disappearance, Angela lived on Lake Montonia Road with family members. Angela's aunt was the last person to see her at the residence before she vanished. Her aunt recalls seeing her sitting outside the home with a duffel bag and a teddy bear, as if she was waiting for someone to come pick her up.

It appears nobody in the family actually saw Angela leaving the residence. However, a family friend reported seeing her getting into the black sedan near the residence around 5:00 PM. The driver of the vehicle is described as a black man with black hair and a goatee. It appears that nobody in Angela's family knew this man, and he has still never been identified.

Angela's family reported her missing on April 28th, 2021. It was noted that she had disappeared for short periods before in the past, but it was unusual for her to stay out of touch with family, especially her daughter. Detectives followed leads when the case was first opened but were unable to find anything substantial. Months turned into years without any sign of Angela as her disappearance became a cold case. 

Over three years after Angela disappearance, in August 2024, it was reported that new leads had prompted a large-scale search for her in a wooded area of Gaston County. Investigators stated that the leads were brought on by advances in technology that allowed them to narrow down a "more fine point of a last known contact area for [Angela]", which is what lead the investigators to that area.

The search was conducted by over 60 people from several different law enforcement agencies. Over 20 acres of land was scoured, but nothing was found. Despite this, investigators stated that they have not given up on their search for Angela and are now seeking more leads in the case.

Angela's family members have also not given up hope that they will find answers. If you have any information that could lead to Angela's whereabouts, please contact the Kings Mountain Police Department at 704-734-0444.
-
UPDATE (March 2025): Angela's remains have been found and identified.

In April 2022 - about a year after Angela vanished - human remains were found in Gastonia. It took 3 years for the remains to be identified, but on February 25th, 2025, officials confirmed that the remains were that of Angela Burris.

An investigation into her death is ongoing.




Saturday, February 8, 2025

The Murder of Kellie Owens

 

Kellie Owens was murdered inside her Charlotte, North Carolina residence on December 27th, 2007. The 30-year-old woman was shot to death in her apartment's bathroom. Kellie's boyfriend reportedly found her suffering from a gunshot wound and called 9-1-1. Medics announced her dead on the scene. 

Kellie's daughter, who was only 2 years old at the time, was found unharmed in her crib in a separate bedroom. Detectives believe the toddler was placed there by someone other than Kellie, as it was uncommon for the child to be left in the crib. It was also noted that there were no signs of forced entry into the apartment, which suggests that the killer might have been someone known to Kellie.

The death of Kellie was a devastating loss for not only her family, but also the community. Kellie worked with at-risk youth and was loved by the children she interacted with. She was also a loving mother, but she unfortunately never got to see her daughter grow up.

Several years have passed, and the murder remains unsolved. In 2024, a detective working the case told reporters that "the physical evidence in this case does not help us get any closer to making an arrest." Though it appears several interviews have been conducted, and several people have been investigated, police have not been able to gather needed evidence to move forward in the case.

Both detectives and Kellie's family loved ones have appealed to the public for someone with information to come forward. If you have any information that could lead to the arrest of Kellie's killer(s), please contact Charlotte-Mecklenburg Violent Crimes Division at 704-336-2358. 

Saturday, January 18, 2025

The Murder of Crystal 'Jersey' Baker

Source: Durham Crimestoppers

On January 22nd, 2010, authorities in Durham, North Carolina received a call about a burglary near Chandler Road and Ross Road. Officers arrived on the scene and went on pursuit of the suspected burglar into the nearby woods. While searching for the suspect, the officers stumbled upon something unexpected: the body of a young woman. 

The deceased was later identified as 24-year-old Crystal 'Jersey' Baker. Her death was quickly declared a homicide, as she had been brutally beaten and stabbed. The autopsy report states that Crystal had not only suffered blunt force trauma to the head, but she also was "stabbed 21 times in the face, eight times in the back, three times in the abdomen and once each in the neck, in each thigh and above the right buttock."

There has been very little reporting on Crystal's life and/or the events leading up to her death. Some reports state that Crystal was last seen at Budget Inn on Holloway Street before she found deceased, but further details are unknown. Said Budget Inn is approximately 2 miles away from the area where her body was found. 

According to court records, Crystal had a criminal record and had faced charges for drug paraphernalia possession and breaking and entering. She was sentenced to community service and probation for possession/use of drug paraphernalia in December 2009 - a month before she was killed. Authorities have not commented on whether or not they believe drugs played a role in Crystal's murder.

The violent nature of Crystal's death suggests that her killer(s) acted with extreme hatefulness. In addition to the blunt force trauma and the stabbings, Crystal also was found with lacerations around her genital area - though there was no further evidence of sexual assault. It was also noted that she was not wearing shoes and was only wearing one sock when she was found.

Several years have passed, and Crystal's homicide still remains unsolved. News about the investigation has been minimal, but the case is still classified as open. If you have any information that could lead to Crystal's murder being solved, please contact Durham authorities at 919-560-4118​ or submit a tip online. 

-
Sources:
Durham Crimestoppers
Durham NC Gov
North Carolina DOC
WRAL, (2) (3)
 

Saturday, December 21, 2024

The Disappearance and Homicide of Margaret 'Maggie' Stickler

Source: Legacy.com

Margaret 'Maggie' Stickler vanished from Richmond, Virginia on April 16th, 2022. The then-21-year-old woman was reportedly last seen alive near local motels on Chamberlayne Avenue and Brookland Park Boulevard. After this last sighting, Maggie's communications with her family ceased, and her social media activity abruptly stopped. She was later reported missing by her mother.

Maggie is originally from Botetourt County, Virginia and grew up in Fincastle. According to her mother, Maggie relocated to Richmond to complete a drug rehabilitation/continuing drug abstinence program. She reportedly battled with drug addiction for at least a year and a half prior to her disappearance. 

Despite Maggie's struggles, she still kept in touch with her family. She spoke to her mother on the phone on the same day of her disappearance, and nothing seemed amiss during their conversation. However, at some point later that day, Maggie vanished. 

Six months later, in October 2022, human remains were found in a wooded area near Elm City, North Carolina. It took nearly a year, but in August of 2023, those remains were identified as that of Margaret 'Maggie' Stickler. Her death was labeled a homicide. 

Over two years have passed since Maggie was found deceased, but the case still remains unsolved. Both family members and investigators alike are left with several questions, namely: Who killed Maggie? How did she end up in Elm City?

-
The initial investigation.        

Source: ABC 8

As previously noted, Maggie was last seen alive in Richmond, Virginia on April 16th, 2022. She spoke with her mother on the phone that day, and said she'd call again the following day. The family did reportedly receive a "Happy Easter" text from Maggie's phone in a group chat the following day - but the phone call never came.

Then, all attempts to reach Maggie went unanswered. Her social media activity abruptly stopped. After days of silence, Maggie's mother finally contacted police to report her daughter missing. 

Throughout the investigation, it was revealed that Maggie's boyfriend, Mitchell Cooper, was amongst the last people to have seen Maggie alive. When questioned, Cooper told police that he last saw Maggie leaving the Richmond Motel on Chamberlayne Avenue. There were reportedly other sightings of Maggie in or around the same area later that day. After that, the trail seemingly went cold. 

It was noted that, after the initial questioning, Cooper quickly retained an attorney and became uncooperative with the investigation. In June 2023, Richmond police Detective Clarence Key told reporters that Cooper was a "person of interest" in Maggie's disappearance. However, to this day, Cooper has not been charged with anything related to the case.

Remains found near Elm City, NC.

On October 15th, 2022 - almost exactly 6 months after Maggie's disappearance - hunters in Wilson County, North Carolina found human skeletal remains in a wooded area south of Elm City. The state's medical examiner determined that the deceased was likely a "Caucasian woman between 20-25 years old with auburn hair." Investigators revealed that the woman had been a victim of homicide; having likely been killed in a different location before her body was left in the woods. 

The human remains were found 150 miles away from Richmond, Virginia - where Maggie was last seen. As such, Maggie's name initially did not even come up on detective's short list of possible identities for the human remains. In January 2023, it was reported that investigators had entered descriptions of the victim into NamUs, and five possible matches came up. However, dental records ruled out all five people.

Many people in Wilson County speculated about the remains possibly belonging to either 20-year-old Isabel 'Chaveli' Palacios or 35-year-old Tammy Grady - as both women vanished from the area. However, investigators were unable to match the remains to either woman. 

August 2023: Maggie is identified.

Ten months after the remains were found, it was finally confirmed through DNA that the body was that of Margaret 'Maggie' Stickler. Her family was soon notified that not only was Maggie deceased, but her death was a homicide, and her body had been hidden. Shortly thereafter, her family shared the following message:

"It is with saddened and broken hearts that we share that the search for Maggie Stickler has ended. Her remains were discovered last October in North Carolina and we have now confirmed her identity. Maggie’s struggles are over. She will soon be at peace. We are in the process of bringing her home and have scheduled services for Labor Day weekend...We would like to thank you all for your unwavering support. Your calls, texts and messages have been incredible and we are eternally grateful. We ask that you allow us time to process and grieve in private.

A beautiful light has been extinguished and our world will never be the same.

RIP sweet Maggie"

Source: WTVR.com

What happened to Maggie?

To this day, no arrests have been made related to Maggie's case. Based on the known information and speculation, a few theories can be made - but it should be noted that, at this time, nothing has been confirmed. 

When Maggie was first reported missing, there was speculation that her battles with addiction played a role in her disappearance. Reports state that she initially lived in a recovery residence in Richmond, but shortly before her disappearance, she was staying at a motel. There was various online speculation that Maggie might have been in active addiction and was avoiding her family out of shame. Other speculation was even more grim - that she had possibly overdosed and was yet to be found. 

There was (and still is) inevitable speculation about Maggie's boyfriend, Mitchell Cooper, as well. Not only was he one of the last known people to have seen Maggie alive, but he was also quick to hire a lawyer and stop cooperating with police. Additionally, Richmond Detective Key told reporters that Cooper was a person of interest back in June 2023. 

Said June 2023 report was before Maggie's remains were identified. Since the confirmation of Maggie's death, police have not mentioned anything further about Cooper. Still, it appears that he has not been ruled out, either. 

While detectives have confirmed that they are investigating Maggie's death as a homicide, they have otherwise remained quiet about the status of the investigation.  

An open case.

The homicide of Margaret 'Maggie' Stickler remains open and unsolved. If you have any information that could help the investigation, please contact the Wilson Police Department at 252-399-2323 or the Richmond Police Department at 804-646-5125.

-
Sources:
10 News
Charley Project
The Wilson Times
WTVR, (2)

Saturday, April 27, 2024

The Murder of Jenna Franks

Source: FBI.gov

On February 24th, 2021, street division workers in Jacksonville, North Carolina were clearing debris in a wooded area near Ellis Boulevard and White Street when they found something unexpected: a human body. Police responded to the scene, and it was quickly determined that a murder had taken place. The victim was subsequently identified as 34-year-old Jenna Franks.

Shortly after news broke about her murder, it was announced that the case was being investigated as a possible hate crime. Jenna was a transgender woman and had active involvement with the Onslow County LGBTQ+ Community Center. Her death has been a devastating loss for both Jenna's loved ones and members of the community. 

Authorities initially did not reveal many details about Jenna's death; only that she had been murdered, and that the FBI was assisting with the investigation. Months later, in June 2021, the results of Jenna's autopsy were revealed. The report states that she was "stabbed multiple times in the neck and lower half of her body." 

The FBI has also revealed that they believe Jenna "willingly met up with whoever is responsible for her death, not knowing her life would end." Investigators also believe it is likely that the killer is familiar with the area where Jenna's body was found. On the three-year anniversary of Jenna's murder, a detective told reporters that it's possible that the killer "may continue to live or work in the community."

Investigators ask that anyone who knew Jenna or might have information about her murder to come forward. A monetary reward is available in exchange for information that leads to the arrest and conviction of Jenna's killer(s). If you have any information that could help the investigation, please submit a tip. 

 
-
Sources:
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Jacksonville Daily News
Human Rights Campaign
News & Observer
WNCT, (2)

Saturday, February 10, 2024

The Murder of Alkia Rodgers

source: wcnc.com

Alkia Rodgers was found brutally murdered at the age of 18 on May 22nd, 2003. The teen girl left her family's Charlotte, North Carolina home the previous evening to meet up with the father of her infant son at Southside Park. Alkia never returned home, and her family later reported her missing. 

The following day, children playing on Southside Park's playground made a gruesome discovery at the top of the slide: the body of a teenage girl. That teenage girl was later identified as Alkia Rodgers. An autopsy later confirmed that Alkia's throat had been slit, and she had also been strangled. 

Southside Park is located just 1,000 feet away from Alkia's residence. She often took her infant son to the park to play. The park was also established as a meet-up spot between Alkia and her son's father, as he would often bring "diapers, food, and other things" to the park for Alkia to bring back home to their child. 

According to reports, Alkia planned to meet up with her son's father at the park that evening so he could give her diapers for their son. Due to this, her son's father immediately became a suspect after Alkia was found murdered at their meet-up spot. In 2019, cold case detective Ed Williams told reporters that Alkia's son's father was "questioned extensively, but nothing has ever been proven." Detective Williams maintained that he is still a suspect, but there are "lots of people" who are still suspects as well. 

However, DNA that was collected from the scene reportedly does not match Alkia's son's father. At this time, it does not appear that detectives have made a match of the DNA to any person who has been investigated for Alkia's murder. It also does not appear that the DNA matches anyone in their database. 

Despite this, investigators are confident that Alkia's murder was not random; that she likely knew her killer. Detective Williams specifically noted that the way in which Alkia was savagely killed indicates that her death was personal. He explained, "Usually when someone is strangled like that and cut in [the] throat, it's usually people that know each other."

Over two decades have passed, and Alkia's murder still remains unsolved. Both Alkia's family members and investigators hope that somebody with information about Alkia's murder will come forward. If you have any information that could help the investigation, please CMPD's Cold Case Unit at 704-336-2358. 

-
Sources:
Charlotte-Mecklinburg Police Department
WCNC, (2)
 

Wednesday, April 12, 2023

Timeline: The Case of Katie and Steven Pladl

Katie Pladl (18) and her biological father Steven Pladl (42) pictured together in 2016

The story of Katie and Steven Pladl is one of the wildest cases I have ever covered. The disturbing and tragic story has caused a lot of discussion on the case's tumblr post. While the post covers the overall story, this timeline breaks down the details in chronological order. 

1995: 20-year-old Steven Pladl meets 15-year-old Alyssa Garcia on the Internet.

Alyssa Garcia (source)

January 1998: 17-year-old Alyssa gives birth to a baby girl fathered by Steven. They name the little girl Denise. 

Steven and Alyssa's baby girl (source)

1998 cont.: According to Alyssa, Steven was abusive towards their infant daughter. Alyssa alleged that Steven would pinch Denise “until her body was left black and blue. The cruel father would also stuff Katie in a cooler to drown out her crying, preventing Alyssa from freeing the terrified infant until she was on the verge of suffocating.” (DailyMail). Despite this, though, Alyssa stays with Steven and eventually ends up marrying him. 

1998 cont.: Alyssa and Steven place Denise up for adoption. She is adopted by Anthony and Kelly Fusco. The baby's new name is Katie Fusco, and she is moved to Anthony and Kelly's home in Dutchess County, New York. 

Town in New York, where Katie moved as an infant after being adopted by the Fuscos

2007: Almost 10 years after giving birth to Katie, Alyssa gives birth to her and Steven's second child--a baby girl. Alyssa stated that they were “more grown up and ready” to have children at this stage in life.

2012: Alyssa gives birth to their third daughter.

2016: Katie, now 18 years old, grows curious about her biological family. She tracks down Alyssa, now 37, and Steven, now 42, on social media. The estranged parents and daughter begin to correspond.

Katie Fusco at age 18 (source)

June 2016: Katie graduates from high school. She has plans to enroll in the local community college and then eventually transfer to SUNY Purchase to study digital advertising.

August 2016: After continuing to correspond with her birth parents, Katie’s plans change. Instead of enrolling in college, she opts to move to Henrico, Virginia to live with Steven, Alyssa, and their other two daughters. 

Alyssa Pladl and Katie Pladl reunited in 2016 - pictured together with Alyssa and Steven's two younger daughters (source)

September 2016: Steven begins sleeping on Katie’s bedroom floor each night. According to Alyssa, she and Steven had already been sleeping in separate beds for months prior. 

Sept-Nov. 2016: Steven and Katie begin a sexual relationship.

November 2016: Alyssa moves out of the home and files for divorce from Steven. They split custody of the two younger children. Alyssa allegedly had suspicions about Steven’s relationship with Katie but was not completely aware of how far it had gone. 

Late 2016-Early 2017: Steven instructs his two younger daughters to begin referring to Katie as their stepmom rather than their sister. At some point, Katie learns she is pregnant with Steven's child.

Katie and Steven in 2017, while Katie was pregnant (source

May 23rd, 2017: Alyssa reads her 11-year-old daughter’s diary after a visit with Steven and Katie. From there, Alyssa learns that her ex-husband was engaging in a sexual relationship with their oldest biological daughter. She also learns that Katie is pregnant with Steven’s baby. After confronting Steven about it, Alyssa decides to contact the police. 


Pages from the diary of Alyssa and Steven's 11-year-old, describing Steven's relationship with Katie. Click to enlarge. (source)

May 31st, 2017: Henrico County police officers interview Steven and Alyssa’s two other children. No arrests are made.

Summer 2017: Katie and Steven move to Knightdale, North Carolina. 

July 20th, 2017: Katie and Steven get married in Maryland. Their marriage was official; they were able to “legally” wed because they did not disclose their father-daughter relationship. Their wedding ceremony was complete with guests, including Steven’s parents and Katie’s adoptive parents. Katie’s adoptive parents reportedly felt there was “nothing they could do except support Katie.” (CBSnews)

Katie, Steven & family at their July 2017 wedding (dailymail)

September 1st, 2017: Katie gives birth to her father’s baby. They name the little boy Bennett. 

Katie with Bennett (2017)

November 29th, 2017: Henrico County police officers issue arrest warrants for Steven and Katie.

Late January 2018: Steven and Katie are arrested and charged with incest and adultery. They are later released on bond and ordered to have no-contact with one another. Katie moves back to New York with her adoptive parents. Steven’s mother gains custody of their son.


April 2018: Katie decides to end her relationship with Steven. Despite the no-contact order, Katie calls Steven to break-up with him.

April 11th, 2018: Steven picks up his and Katie’s baby from his mother’s house. He brings the baby back to his house, where he later suffocates him and leaves his body in a closet.

April 11th-12th, 2018: Steven drives through the night from North Carolina to New York.

April 12th, 2018: Steven waits outside of the home of Katie’s adoptive parents. He watched as Katie and her adoptive father left together in a vehicle. He followed the two as they drove from Wingdale to New Milford. While stopped at a stop sign between routes 7 and 55, Steven shot Katie and her adoptive father, killing them both, before turning the gun on himself.

Scene where Steven shot Anthony Fusco and Katie before turning the gun on himself

Unfortunately, this disturbing tale ended violently. An officer working the case stated, “we may never understand the mindset or motives of Steven Pladl, but we do know his actions have shattered the lives of countless people.”

Additionally, this case has brought more attention to a term called "genetic sexual attraction", which is "used to describe the intense physical and emotional feelings that some people experience following restored contact between an adopted person and a close member of his or her birth family. Some people believe genetic attraction to be a delayed by-product of “missed bonding". Believe it or not, Katie and Steven are not the first father-and-daughter couple to fall in love. A list of other similar cases can be found here. More information about GSA can be found here.

Friday, October 21, 2022

The Disappearance and Death of Sarah Hill

image source

Sarah Hill has been missing since June 6th, 2018. The then-33-year-old was last known to be in the area of Mount Airy, Virginia. On the evening she vanished, Sarah called her sister and said she was on Blue Hollow Road and needed a ride. Her sister was working at a hospital in Elkin at the time and was unable to assist. Sarah's phone died shortly after that phone call, and she has never been seen or heard from again.

After Sarah was reported missing, her vehicle was found abandoned in a parking lot near the Blue Hollow Road intersection. The car reportedly did not provide any clues to her whereabouts. There are also very few details available about the events leading up to Sarah's disappearance. It's known that her address was listed in Patrick County, Virginia, but she often stayed with friends in both North Carolina and West Virginia.

According to reports, Sarah's friends in West Virginia were contacted, but they did not know of whereabouts or that she had even gone missing. It seems likely that her friends in North Carolina were investigated as well, especially since her car was found on the N.C. 89 - close to the North Carolina-Virginia border. However, no persons of interest have ever been publicly named.

In January 2019, investigators received information that led them to a day-long search at King Park Circle, located just off of Blue Hollow Road. The search involved investigators from several different agencies. Search canines are excavators were used, but no information was released about what - if anything - was found. Investigators returned to the location in July 2020 for a follow up, but no further information was released after that search either.

Since then, it appears that there have not been any updates in Sarah's case. She remains missing today. If you have any information that could lead to her whereabouts, please contact authorities in Virginia at 276-694-3161 or authorities in North Carolina at 757-294-5271.

-

UPDATE (October 2022): Sarah's remains have been found. 

Reports state that Surry County investigators found her remains after obtaining a warrant for a property in Westfield, North Carolina. While searching the home, the detectives found human remains under the house's floorboard. Days later, those remains were identified as Sarah Hill.

At this time, police are not revealing more information about the investigation into Sarah's death. The case is ongoing. 

Charley Project
Mt. Airy News
WFMY News 2
Websleuths

Monday, October 10, 2022

The Disappearance of Brandee Hope Canipe

image source

Brandee Hope Canipe vanished at the age of 29 during May 2006. The young woman resided in Mocksville, North Carolina at the time of her disappearance. Those closest to Brandee describe her as a free spirit who had a habit of taking off and staying out-of-touch for long periods of time. Due to this, Brandee was not reported missing until April 2010 – nearly four years after she disappeared. 

Brandee grew up in Shelby, North Carolina, and she was the oldest of four sisters. According to the sisters, Brandee was a fun and loving sibling. She had a particularly strong relationship with her sister Staley, who was the closest to her in age. However, as the sisters grew into their teenage years, Brandee began to move in a separate direction. She moved out of her family’s home at a young age and only kept in touch with her family sporadically. 

It was not uncommon for Brandee’s family members to go months without hearing from her. Whenever she would reach out, she would let her family know where she was located. Brandee reportedly would stay in various places throughout North Carolina – such as Winston-Salem and Mocksville. She also lived in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina at some point. 

Throughout the years, Brandee gave birth to three children: two daughters and one son. Brandee's daughters lived with her parents, while her son lived with his father. She also got married twice and was known to some as Brandee McCluney or Brandee Rackley. 

Brandee's sister Staley first began to worry about Brandee's wellbeing when she did not show up for a funeral. The mother of Brandee's ex-husband had passed away. Brandee was reportedly quite close with her, even after the divorce. Although it had been years since Staley had heard from Brandee at this point, she still expected to see her at her ex-mother-in-law's funeral. After Brandee was a no-show, Staley began to think something was off.

Eventually, Staley decided to contact police about Brandee's disappearance. Brandee was officially reported missing on April 19th, 2010. Throughout the investigation, detectives were able to determine that she was last seen on May 6th, 2006. The last known sighting of her occurred in Mocksville - where she was living at the time she vanished. The four-year gap between Brandee's disappearance and when she was finally reported missing further deepened the mystery.

 
--

A delayed investigation.

Since years passed before Brandee was actually reported missing, detectives were quite behind on their investigation. It was noted that there had not been any activity in her bank account or her Social Security number since 2006. Brandee's driver's license expired in 2008 but was never renewed. All of these findings made it clear that Brandee had been missing for quite some time. 

Obtaining information from those closest to Brandee was proven to be difficult, as many of them did not have clear memories of their last known interaction with her. Still, Brandee's family members did their best to relay the most accurate information they had and/or could remember.

Information from the family.

Brandee's parents both passed away in 2010 - shortly after she was reported missing. Unfortunately, they were not able to provide much information. However, Brandee's other family members have been in touch with detectives over the years.

All of Brandee's family members corroborated that she lived a somewhat transient lifestyle, and that it was not unusual for months to pass without hearing from her. Several of Brandee's family members also told detectives that they saw Brandee driving a 4-door Buick sedan when she would come to visit. It's possible that Brandee was driving this car at the time of her disappearance but said vehicle has never been located.

Brandee's sister Staley said that she last saw Brandee during 2005, at a bar in Shelby. According to Staley, Brandee was working at the bar. She had gotten a job there after returning to Shelby to be closer to her two daughters. However, it appears that Brandee moved to Mocksville a few months later. 

Leigh, the youngest of Brandee's three younger sisters, said that she last saw Brandee during the spring of 2006. Leigh was only 10 years-old at the time, but she remembers that Brandee had come to visit during that time period. Leigh explained that Brandee had driven her to her school bus stop. The two chatted as they waited in Brandee's car for Leigh's bus to arrive. When the bus finally did arrive, Leigh exited the car, unaware that she would never see her sister again. 

All three of Brandee's children were under the age of 10 during 2006. It's likely that the memories of their mother were a bit fuzzy by the time she was finally reported missing in 2010. Brandee's second oldest daughter, Autumn, spoke to reporters in 2022 and said that she does not remember the exact last time she saw her mother, but the memories she does have of her are quite fond. 

The lake house.

According to a report by Dateline, Brandee's youngest sister Leigh has been more active in the investigation during more recent years. Throughout Leigh's quest for answers, she remembered a detail about Brandee's life prior to her disappearance that might be significant. It involved a lake house.

Leigh explained that, during the fall of 2005, her family faced some financial hardships. During such times, Brandee invited their mother, Leigh, and their other sister, Paige, to come live with her in Mocksville - an approximate hour and a half's drive away from Shelby. The residence belonged to Brandee's boyfriend. 

The three of them lived with Brandee and her boyfriend for a few months. Leigh and Paige were both enrolled in school in Mocksville. After a few months, though, their mother returned to Shelby. Leigh and Paige stayed and continued to live with Brandee.

A short time later, Brandee announced that she and her boyfriend had broken up, so they had to move out of Mocksville. By Leigh's account, Brandee moved them an approximate 45-minute drive away to a lake house located on Belews Creek on the north side of Winston-Salem. Leigh said she is unsure about how, exactly, Brandee became connected to this place - but she did meet a man who reportedly managed the property.

Belews Creek. Source: Forsynth Realty

The man lived in a separate nearby house on the lake. Leigh explained that he had given Brandee and the girls permission to live in their respective house. The nature of Brandee's relationship with this man is unclear, but Leigh does not recall seeing a wife or any other woman in this man's house.

Leigh and Paige lived at that lake house for a bit before CPS was called and told that the girls were not with their custodial parent. The two girls then went to go live with their father. Leigh said that Brandee came to visit her that final time a week later - when she drove her to her school bus stop. 

Leigh was unable to provide detectives with an actual address to this lake house, as she was only 10 years old when she lived there. Detectives went to the area where they believed it might have been located, but there is apparently only new construction there now. Additionally, investigators were never able to identify the property manager. 

The Mocksville residence.

It's unclear if Brandee returned to the lake house after that final interaction with Leigh. According to detectives, Brandee lived in Mocksville at the time she vanished - which was only a short time later. In fact, one of the investigators stated that Brandee's two daughters lived with her at the Mocksville residence in May 2006 - right before she disappeared. 

This is the same residence that Brandee lived in before, with Leigh and Paige. As previously noted, the home belonged to a boyfriend of Brandee's. When investigators finally went to house in 2010, said boyfriend still lived there.

The home was thoroughly investigated, but unfortunately nothing of significance was found. Nothing was found to indicate that any sort of foul play involving Brandee had occurred in the house. It should be noted that four years is plenty of time for evidence to fade or be removed - but still, even a thorough search with professionals turned up no evidence. 

Detectives also investigated the ex-boyfriend himself, but ultimately did not find any evidence against him. One of the investigators working the case specifically said, "there was nothing to list him as a suspect." It's unclear if he has been completely ruled out, but he is not considered a suspect either. 

The vehicle.

As previously stated, Brandee drove a 4-door Buick sedan prior to her disappearance. Many family members corroborated seeing her in this vehicle. Leigh said that Brandee was in this car when she drove her to the bus stop during their final interaction. 

Unfortunately, investigators have not been able to locate this vehicle. That might mean that the car disappeared with Brandee, but it also might not have. Investigators stated that they do not believe the car was registered to Brandee's name, which has made it more difficult to locate. 

Still, there is inevitable speculation that the car did, in fact, vanish with Brandee. As such, there is also speculation that both Brandee and the car ended up in a body of water. In 2021, a volunteer dive group called "Exploring With Nug" did a sonar search in Belews Creek. One of the detectives explained that the dive team used sonar all throughout the lake. Some sunken boats and tires were spotted, but no vehicles. 

In late September 2022, another volunteer dive team conducted a search a Belews Creek. Unfortunately, their search efforts were halted by Hurricane Ian. At this time, it is unknown if they will return to the creek at a later date. 

Theories.

As just mentioned, there has been inevitable speculation that both Brandee and her car ended up in a body of water. The body of water that the volunteer dive teams searched - Belews Creek - is the location where Brandee temporarily lived in a lake house. However, investigators have been adamant that Brandee was last seen alive in Mocksville. In fact, one detective said that he was not sure that she ever returned to the lake house. It's still entirely possible that Brandee returned to there after May 6th, but this has never been confirmed. 

If Brandee did, in fact, return to the lake house after May 6th, 2006, the property manager is definitely worth investigating. Unfortunately, detectives were unable to identify this man. He is still unknown to this day. 

There is also inevitable speculation about Brandee's ex-boyfriend. She was known to be living at his home off US 158 before she vanished. That residence is also the last place that Brandee was seen. As previously noted, the ex-boyfriend was questioned, and he has not been labeled a suspect. It's possible that he was able to destroy any evidence that might have connected him to Brandee's disappearance - as he had a four-year head start on the investigation. Still, at this time, he has not been charged with anything related to Brandee's case.

It's also possible that something or someone else altogether is responsible for Brandee's disappearance. As of 2022, no persons of interest or suspects have been identified.

Where the case stands today.

Brandee still remains missing. Her case remains open. Brandee's youngest sister, Leigh, has been posting about Brandee's case on her Tik Tok.  Her Tik Tok's have helped spread more awareness about Brandee's disappearance. News sources, including Dateline, have begun to report on the case. 

Brandee's family members are hoping to find answers. If you have any information that could help the investigation, please contact the Davie County Sheriff’s Office at 336-751-6238.

-
Sources:
Charley Project
Davie County Enterprise Record
Leigh's Tik Tok
NBC News
Websleuths

Monday, September 19, 2022

The Murder of Denita Smith

Denita Smith (top), Shannon Crawley (bottom left), and Jermeir Stroud (bottom right)


Denita Smith was only 25 years-old when she was savagely murdered by her fiancĂ©’s lover, Shannon Crawley, on January 4th, 2007. Prior to her murder, Denita appeared to be in a great place in life. She was a graduate student at North Carolina Central University in Durham; aspiring to be a photojournalist. Denita was also happily engaged to a man named Jermeir Stroud, who worked as a police officer in Greensboro, North Carolina.

Denita was completely unaware that Jermeir was also involved in a sexual relationship with Shannon. Jermeir and Shannon met after Shannon began working as a 911 operator in Greensboro County. Jermeir hid his affair from Denita, however Shannon was aware of Jermeir’s engagement to Denita.

Over time, Shannon grew jealous of Jermeir’s relationship with Denita. That jealousy was deepened when Shannon saw Jermeir and Denita together for the first time, holding hands as they walked into church. It is believed that at that moment, Shannon decided she wanted her romantic rival gone. 

Shannon decided to put her plan in motion on January 4th, 2007. During that afternoon, she brought a gun and hid outside of Denita’s apartment, waiting for her to leave. When Denita finally emerged, Shannon fired two shots into the back of Denita’s head before fleeing the scene. 

Denita’s body was later found by a maintenance employee. Police were called, who initially thought that Denita had suffered a fatal fall. However, upon closer inspection, it was clear that Denita had been brutally executed. 

The maintenance man who found Denita’s body told police that he saw a woman crying and running away from the apartment complex shortly after he heard gunfire. That woman was seen driving away in a Ford Explorer. Investigators also learned that Denita’s fiancĂ© Jermeir was having “issues” with a woman named Shannon Crawley. 

Eventually, investigators learned about Jermeir and Shannon’s affair. After that, police were able to link that Ford Explorer to Shannon. Five days after Denita’s death, on January 9th, 2007, Shannon was arrested and charged with murder. 

Shannon pleaded not guilty and went to trial in 2010, during which the prosecution stated that Denita did not know Jermeir and Shannon were having an affair and she had absolutely no clue that she was in danger the day she was shot. Shannon’s defense tried to pin the murder on Jermeir, but the jury ultimately did not buy their story. 

Shannon was found guilty of first-degree murder on February 22nd, 2010. The judge immediately sentenced her to life in prison without parole. She remains behind bars today. 

--
Other cases involving infidelity: